Thursday, December 29, 2016

Thank you, from Henry Hessing



I am extremely honored to be receiving “The Frank Patti Award” and “The Individual Achievement Award”.

I am earnestly grateful for the recognition, as no one could fail to be deeply moved by such a tribute, coming from the American Society of Civil Engineers Metropolitan Section Long Island Branch that I love and have served so long. It fills me with emotion I cannot express.

I am especially happy to receive the Frank Patti Award from Frank. If you have not had a chance, speak with Frank, inquire about the fascinating projects he did during his career, and yet still created the time to found the LI Branch.
Thank you so much Frank.
Top of Form

The Individual Achievement Award I truly believe symbolizes the code of conduct of the civil engineering profession. To me, this is the meaning of the award. For all eyes and for all time, it is an expression of the ethics of the American Civil Engineer. That I should be integrated in this way with so noble an ideal arouses a sense of pride and yet of humility which will be with me always.


Top of Form
My individual code of conduct is based on a philosophy expressed by Ayn Rand, in essence  “the concept of man as an heroic being, with his own happiness as the moral purpose of his life, with productive achievement as his noblest activity, and reason as his only absolute.”

Paraphrasing General Douglas MacArthur:
“These concepts teach you to be proud and unbending in honest failure, but humble and gentle in success; not to substitute words for action; not to seek the path of comfort, but to face the stress and spur of difficulty and challenge; to learn to stand up in the storm, but to have compassion on those who fall; to master yourself before you seek to master others; to have a heart that is clean, a goal that is high; to learn to laugh, yet never forget how to weep; to reach into the future, yet never neglect the past; to be serious, yet never take yourself too seriously; to be modest so that you will remember the simplicity of true greatness; the open mind of true wisdom, the meekness of true strength.
They give you a temper of the will, a quality of the imagination, a vigor of reason, a freshness of the deep springs of life, a temperamental predominance of courage over timidity, an appetite for adventure over love of ease. They create in your heart the sense of wonder, the unfailing hope of what next, and the joy and inspiration of life. They teach you in this way to be a gentleman and an engineer”.




I have faced several challenges on my way here, but each one of them has only strengthened me to make me a thorough professional who knows exactly what he wants to accomplish; someone who sets his eyes on the goal, an individual who does not lose sight of it, unless it is achieved. As Robert Moses might say, “gets the job done”.


Winning this award would not have been possible without the inspiration I have received from those who were the senior engineers when I was young, my civil engineering colleagues for whom I have the deepest respect, and from whom I have derived the strength to challenge myself and perform better at each stage of a lifetime in engineering.

I sincerely thank the ASCE Met Section Long Island Branch, the Board, every one of you in our profession, and especially my family. I thank our sons for taking time from their hectic schedules, and their own families to share this evening.

Most importantly, I thank Joni, my wife of 43 years, who has been the “bright spot in my day”, every day, for helping me reach a stage where I can proudly hold up these awards as marks of achievement. 

Thank you!

VIBRATION ANALYSIS REPORT

VILLAGE OF OCEAN BEACH – BULKHEAD AND FERRY TERMINAL REHABILITATION




Vibration Limits for Buildings
                                     

Vibration Limits for Buildings
Scope of Report
The purpose of this report is to identify potential issues with the buildings surrounding the boat basin and establishing recommended vibration limits at the property lines to ensure damage does not occur to the adjacent properties located in Ocean Beach, Fire Island.

Introduction
Construction activities have the potential to produce vibration levels that may be annoying or disturbing to humans and may cause damage to structures. Architectural and/or structural damage may occur if appropriate precautions are not taken.
Effects of ground-borne vibration include discernable movement of building floors, rattling of windows, shaking of items on shelves or hanging on walls, and rumbling sounds. Construction related activity can create vibration waves that propagate through the various soil and rock strata to the foundations of nearby structure, certain resonant, or natural, frequencies of various components of the building may be “excited”. In extreme cases vibration can cause damage to buildings.

Types of Vibration Impacts
Measurements of vibrations used in the evaluation are expressed in terms of peak particle velocity (PPV) in inches per second (ips or in/sec). The PPV, a quantity commonly used for vibration measurements, is the maximum velocity experienced by any point in a structure during a vibration event. It is an indication of the magnitude of energy transmitted through vibration. PPV is an indicator often used in determining potential damage to buildings from stress associated with blasting and other construction activities.
One of the more frequently used thresholds for vibration, established by the United States Bureau of Mines, is a PPV of 2.0 ips at the closest structure to prevent structural damage. This level is a typical nominal structural damage criterion employed by construction projects. When most stringent criteria is required, PPV limit of 0.5 ips is used. 0.5 ips is 10 times more restrictive than 2.0 on the logarithmic scale and is associated with protection of surrounding historic structures that are susceptible to cosmetic cracks in fragile plaster. This limit could be lowered to protect fragile and/or historic structures based on a detailed vibration assessment conducted by the construction contractor prior to construction. A quantitative assessment of potential vibration impacts from blasting is not provided as none is anticipated at this time.
Another type of vibration impact is human annoyance which is highly dependent on frequency of occurrence and generally occurs when inside buildings. Ground borne vibration impacts may be somewhat perceptible to people who are outdoors. It is almost never annoying. This is because without shaking of a building or items within a building or the rumble noise that can only occur indoors, vibration does not cause a strong adverse human reaction

Construction Activities
To determine potential impacts of the project’s construction activities, estimates of vibration levels induced by construction equipment at 25 feet are based on the Federal Transit Administration (FTA), “Transit Noise and Vibration Assessment”, April 1995 as up dated in 2006. 
For the equipment anticipated to be used on this project we find:
Table A
Typical Levels of Vibration for Construction Equipment
Similar for that Proposed for Sheet Pile Construction
Construction Activity   PPV at 25 feet              
                                                (ips)                                        
Pile Driver (impact)                   
upper range                   1.518                                       
typical                           0.644                                       
Pile Driver (sonic)                     
upper range                   0.734                                       
typical                           0.170                                       
The values provided in the tables are based on the FTA literature. Actual vibration levels are dependent on construction procedures, soil and geological conditions, and the structural characteristics of the receptor (e.g., foundation and construction type).
PPV at other distances can be calculated. PPV at Distance D = PPV (at 25 feet) * (25/D) raised to the 1.5 power.
The anticipated typical vibration levels for this project using continuous sheet pile driving with PPV at 25 ft = 0.170 in/sec implies:
10 feet                                      0.67 in/sec
15 feet                                      0.37 in/sec
25 feet                                      0.17 in/sec
40 feet                                      0.11 in/sec
And 50 feet                               0.06 in/sec
The further away a building is from sheet pile installation using continuous vibration the smaller the PPV is. The closer the building is to the source of vibration the higher the PPV value becomes.

Table B
Construction Vibration Damage Criteria
Building Category                                                                    PPV (in/sec)
Reinforced-concrete, steel or timber (no plaster)                           0.5 
Engineered concrete and masonry (no plaster)                             0.3 
Non-engineered timber and masonry buildings                              0.2
Buildings extremely susceptible to vibration damage                     0.12

Establishing Vibration Limits to Protect Buildings
One of the most commonly referenced studies is the USBM RI 8507.
Table C
Damage Thresholds as reported by the US Bureau of Mines Report Investigations 8507, Structure Response and Damage Produced by Ground Vibration from Surface Mining Blasting (USBM RI 8507),
Conditions Observed                                                   Typical PPV (in/sec)
Threshold Damage (hairline cracking in plaster,                            2 - 3
Opening of old cracks, etc.)                                                        Never at < 0.5              
Minor damage (hairline cracking in masonry,                                4 - 5                                                                              breaking windows)                                 Never at < 1.0
Major Structure Damage (cracking or
Shifting of foundations or bearing walls)                                       > 5
There are limitations to these findings, however, they are offered as a guideline.

Another study cited in the literature is Swiss Standard SN 640 312 only available in French and German. A partial translation indicates that for most light framed structures, and for continuous vibrations anticipated on this project, the limit is 0.59 in/sec. For fragile or historic buildings subjected to transient vibrations is a range from 0.12 to 0.24 in/sec. depending on professional judgement. Section 12 of the standard provides useful commentary: “If the velocity values occur below the guide values, then the probability of minor damage is extremely small. If the guide values are only rarely exceeded up to about 30%, then the probability that damage occurs is not increased significantly. If the values exceed twice the guide values, then damage (i.e., cosmetic cracking) is likely to occur. Cracks that penetrate through an entire wall or floor have to be expected if values exceed the guide values by several times. If conditions are very special, an expert would be allowed to define higher or lower guide values.

The limit for historical and/or fragile buildings will likely be in the range of 0.12 to 0.5 in/sec depending on evaluation of key factors for the individual case. 

In the examples cited below, vibrations typically originated outside the buildings, and the vibration response (where the limits apply) was measured at the base of the building or near a column or bearing wall within the building, such that dynamic amplification effects were not included. This is consistent with the basis of this paper which assumes that vibrations originate outside the building and are measured at the base of the building.

Examples:
For cases of extreme fragility or where a very high importance factor is desired, the lowest vibration limit that should be set is the maximum ambient level of vibration in the building. This level can be determined by monitoring vibrations in the building for a period of time during normal, day to day activities before construction begins. Per the literature these values are expressed as vibration amplitudes (in/sec) and range between 0.02 – 0.05 for occupants walking or closing doors to 0.10 to 0.14 for moving furniture in an office building. 

For the special case of using vibratory sheet pile driving (i.e., potentially continuous vibrations) within about 30 feet of a structure a lower vibration limit of 0.2 in/sec (frequency-dependent) can be used for any continuous vibrations (defined as cyclic vibrations with duration greater than 2 seconds) . Careful pre- and post - construction surveys of the structure should be conducted by staff to ensure no adverse effects are found.

It should be noted that in 2015, Mr. E. Hammarberg commented that he has been involved in the monitoring of several hundred old (many historic) unreinforced-masonry buildings in New York City and that he has never observed damaged caused by construction vibrations at levels below 0.5 in/sec, which is the stipulated limit for New York City landmark buildings (reference NYC TPPN-1088).


Summary
Using PPV =  0.5 in/sec is an acceptable limit for the project where the distance from driving sheet piling to the base of a structure is 25 feet or greater. The only structure at 10 feet to 15 feet away from the piling is the police station. The allowable PPV should be limited to 0.3 in/sec and could be lowered further in accordance with Table B above.

If at a future time it is determined that a structure is an historic building, the limit for historic buildings will be in the range of 0.12 to 0.5 in/sec depending on evaluations of the key factors for the individual case. For cases of extreme fragility or where a very importance factor is desired, the lowest vibration limit that should be set is the maximum ambient level of vibration in the building. 

Conclusion
PPV = 0.5 in/sec is the recommended acceptable vibration limit for the project with a reduction down to 0.3 in/sec in the vicinity of the police station. The inspection staff monitoring vibration can ask the Contractor to change his operations to reduce the observed PPV if deemed desirable for the project.

References and Notes
City Tunnel No. 3, Stage 2 Manhattan Leg Shaft 33B Final EIS
US Bureau of Mines Report of Investigations 8507, “Structure Response and Damage Produced by Ground Vibration from Surface Mine Blasting” (USBM RI 8507).
Federal Transit Administration (FTA), “Transit Noise and Vibration Assessment”, April 1995 as up dated in 2006.  Also see FTA Noise and Vibration Manual.
Swiss SN 640 312, Swiss Standard SN 640 312, notably J. Struder, translation found in APT Bulletin published by Association of Preservation Technology, credit to: Arne P. Johnson and W. Robert Hannen
“Protection of Historic Urban Structures During Adjacent Construction,” E. Hammarberg et.al.
Sullivan Arch, Art Institute of Chicago

Wednesday, December 18, 2013

John Aliprantis: A Friend Passed Away

John Aliprantis came to the United States as a 6 year old from an island in Greece, not speaking a word of English. He worked, mastered the English language, served in the US Army and received a bachelor’s degree in civil engineering from Columbia University. He was a professional engineer, and senior vice president of Seeley, Stevenson, Value and Knecht, later known as STV Incorporated. John was responsible for the entire civil division, both design and construction, in the New York City office. This work included roads, bridges, airports, and rail. John created a cadre of professional civil engineers who were or became vice presidents capable of managing major projects for our clients. They were Rogers Thackaberry, Dick Posthauer, Jim Hynes, George Shearer, Bruce Smith, Dr. Peter Cheu, and Donald Yue. He gave them responsibility, and let them succeed. He was always there for them, if needed. He cared for the people who worked for him. A patient man, reflective by nature, his hobby was making furniture, an exacting labor of love. Simply try to do wood joinery to see how much effort goes into it. He liked to dabble in stocks as well but John’s life was truly his wife and two sons. The job was second to them. Every once in a while, he’d mention what one or both of his sons had done. And if it was something that most parents would be upset about, he’d shrug it off saying, “Things happen”. John took great pride in Peter and Antonio as they were growing up, making decisions about college, life, home and marriage. John was in St Francis hospital where I saw him for a few short visits late last April. He said he was there because of fluid around the lungs caused by a reaction to medicine. True to his stoic nature, he never mentioned cancer in our conversations. He went to Boston but what was prescribed had a negative effect. He came home and died July 2nd, about a week later. Donald and I went to the viewing. Surprisingly, we were the only ones he worked with who were there. In passing, he was surrounded by his loving family, grand children, relatives, neighbors and friends. He will be missed. Hank Hessing

RECONSTRUCTION OF NORTHERN STATE PARKWAY AND ROUTE 110 INTERCHANGE

This paper will present the historical background, construction complexities and how they were addressed for reconstruction of a major interchange in Suffolk County, New York, the largest construction project in the Region. 1 Historical Background “Construction of the Northern State Parkway began in July 1931 at a ceremony held at the Queens-Nassau border, jointly attended by Robert Moses and Governor Franklin D. Roosevelt. The first section of parkway was completed in 1933. The route of the Northern State Parkway was extended 1934. The standard configuration of the route, was a 44-foot, undivided pavement of four lanes with two in each direction. Mountable concrete curbs edged the turf shoulders that blended into cut slopes. To permit adequate sight distances on curves, graceful coves of lawn were either cut into existing woods or created by planting. Indigenous vegetation (except for the red dogwood, a favorite of Moses), accented the lawn areas. The parkway's design took advantage of the rolling hills that marked the southern end of the glacial moraine. Between 1936 and 1938, the Northern State Parkway was extended to the Wantagh State Parkway (Exit 33) in Westbury. This section was the beneficiary of changes in the parkway design of earlier years. This stretch of the Northern State Parkway, which introduced a nine-foot-wide grass median that separated the opposing roadways, set the design standard for the construction of future parkways on Long Island. The new Northern State Parkway design, which featured two 25-foot-wide, two-lane roadways separated by a variable median measuring as wide as 30 feet, was implemented through eastern Nassau County and western Suffolk County. Utilizing this design, the parkway was extended east to Exit 40 (NY 110) in 1949. Unlike previous sections of the Northern State Parkway, which were designed with a single centerline for the alignment and profile of the roadway, the newer parkway section was designed with two individual roadways separated by a median varying in width from nine to more than fifty feet. The design speed was 75 MPH, which provided superior sight distance across horizontal and vertical curves at an operating speed of 50 MPH. Other design standards, such as 12-foot vertical clearances, wider shoulders, more generous curve and ramp radii, and longer acceleration and deceleration lanes, reflected the more contemporary design standards mandated for roads receiving Federal-aid highway money. In Melville, the New York State Department of Transportation (NYSDOT) planned and designed Exit 40 (NY 110) to address safety and capacity issues. The outmoded cloverleaf interchange was replaced with a five-ramp, modified "diamond" interchange. 2 Reconstruction of Northern State Parkway and Route 110 Interchange Reconstruction of Northern State Parkway and the Route 110 Interchange required replacement of a 70 year old rigid frame bridge carrying Northern State Parkway (NSP) over New York Route 110, two very heavily travelled arterials; the reconfiguration of the NSP/ Rte. 110 interchange from a cloverleaf interchange to a modified diamond interchange; the widening of Route 110 from two lanes to three lanes in each direction; and the improvement of the Route 110 intersection with Old Country Road. Additional work included utility relocation, lighting, drainage and construction of new recharge basins. Work zone traffic control (WZTC) was accomplished utilizing daytime and nighttime lane closures and off-site detours. Standard WZTC layouts following the federal Manual of Uniform Traffic Control (MUTCD) and NY Supplement were required for safety of the traveling public and workers. Field staff worked days, nights and weekends. Inspection services for the project were needed to ensure the quality of the contractor’s work, and to ensure its accordance with contract plans and specifications. Services included detailed inspection, on-site testing of materials, field measurements and data collection for submitting monthly and final construction estimates, progress reports and preparation of record plans. The JV kept project records and documentation in accordance with MURK, applied “Site Manager” software, prepared the RE’s diary describing work progress, problems and resolution. Field staff proactively helped to achieve timely completion by monitoring the adequacy of the contractor’s personnel, equipment, material supplies and CPM schedule. 3 The Project Team The project owner is New York State Department of Transportation. The Department’s designer was GPI. The prime contractor was Grace Industries. HAKS Engineers and GEB Engineers, P.C., formed a joint venture (JV) for Contract D030921, CI PIN 0516.41, Construction Inspection Services at Northern State Parkway Interchange with Route 110 Suffolk County, NYSDOT Region 10. The JV Team included: DBE sub-consultants CSM Engineering, P.C., Affridi Associates and JED Engineering, P.C.. 4 Original or Innovative Application of New or Existing Technology 4.1 Value Engineering “Value Engineering can be defined as an organized approach to the identification and elimination of unnecessary cost”. Source: Value Engineering Definition and Concept, Construction Information Services, Misronet.com The Contractor, Grace Industries, submitted a plan and later, a design to construct a temporary bridge to take both east and west bound traffic, demolish the existing bridge in its entirety, construct the proposed bridge in one stage of construction rather than multiple stages. The plan was analyzed and accepted, with cost savings shared between the contractor and the owner. Approximately seven (7) months were saved. The work was accomplished and stake holders benefitted. In order to accomplish this they proposed to construct a temporary bypass road utilizing Mabey Bridges over Route 110 in order to detour traffic off of the existing Northern State Parkway. 4.2 Major benefits of this plan: • Schedule: This VE plan avoids schedule delays caused by the late Contract award and put the Contract back on its originally scheduled completion date of December 31, 2013. This represented a savings of 8 months. • Quality: The VE plan improved the integrity of the bridge structure by reducing unnecessary longitudinal joints in the superstructure. • Safety: The bypass road allowed the contractor to create a buffer zone separating the travelling public from demolition and construction of the new NSP Bridge thus improving safety to both the public and work crews. This eliminated Stage 2 work that placed construction between the EB & WB lanes. • Value: This VE plan included construction of an earth berm along the boundary line with a cemetery on the southwest corner of the project in the area coincident with Temporary east side ramp and acted as a buffer from Northern State Parkway traffic in lieu of a possible future noise wall. • Cost: The VE plan avoided potential additional cost exposures in the future by avoiding a stage 4 median work zone to install the permanent median barrier retaining walls on NSP. 4.2 Challenges were: • Horizontal and Vertical Alignments – A separate alignment for both eastbound and westbound was required. • Sight distance requirements – Work zone advisory speed limit posted at 40 MPH • Transition from the bridge guiderail to the concrete barrier- Custom-built concrete transition barrier was required 5. Social, Economical and Sustainable Design Considerations 5.1 GreenLITES Certification Levels • Green Leadership In Transportation Environmental Sustainability • Certification level based on total points received. The highest certification goes to designs and operations which clearly advance the state of sustainable transportation solutions. In April 2011, PIN 0516.41 was awarded Evergreen Rating, the highest level of sustainability The Reconstruction of Northern State Parkway over Route 110 interchange project promoted local economic development. Local subcontractors and labor were utilized when possible. This had a positive effect on the local economy, the citizens and other industries not directly associated with the construction work through the natural recirculation of money for purchases and sales taxes. 6. Complexity 6.1 Excavation & Backfill: An extraordinary amount of excavation and backfill was required while concurrently not affecting the existing residential and commercial properties • Unclassified Excavation and Disposal - 130,000 CM • Embankment in Place - 125,000 CM • Selected and Structure Fill - 12,000 CM • Trench and Culvert Excavation 30,000 CM 6.2 Erosion Control The area required for erosion control was quite large. Water flow during flood events required greater control than existed prior to reconstruction. Over 120 acres in the construction area were successfully maintained with erosion control measures that included erosion control blankets, sediment basins, turbidity curtains, silt fences and stone check dams. 6.3 Drainage New and modified drainage systems were installed to improve the quality of storm water runoff. In addition, approximately 100 temporary drainage structures and leaching basins were installed to maintain storm water runoff between stages and to overcome differences in road elevation between east and west bound traffic. To reduce the impact of construction, drainage work requiring lane closures were performed at night. Access to businesses was maintained throughout construction • New Drainage structures, Catch Basins 160 • Temporary drainage Structures 100 • Leaching Basins 30 • Manholes 25 6.4 Demolition The existing concrete rigid frame structure was removed once the temporary detour was opened to traffic. The concrete arch was removed by closing Route 110 to traffic during a weekend closure in order to break up the frame in place and let it fall below. The concrete rigid frame was removed using multiple large crawler excavators (Komatsu PC300, Komatsu PC 400, etc.) equipped with a Labounty pulverizer shear or HY-Ram HR500 hydraulic hammer to break up the structure which was then allowed to fall below the structure. The area beneath the structure was restricted to all personnel during the demolition operation. Protective devices were provided as required to restrict access. The contractor complied with all OSHA Fall Protection regulations and requirements. 6.5 Superstructure Twenty six (26) new pre-stressed concrete girders (AASHTO Type V) are 5’-3” (1.605m) tall and are either 90 ‘ or 115’ long depending on span width. They were erected using a Liebherr LTM 1500-8.1 600 Ton Hydraulic Truck Crane positioned on-grade. The beams were fabricated at Precast System Inc, Allentown NJ. • (11) Interior Beams- 90 feet long 50T • (11) Interior Beams – 115 feet long 63T • (2) Fascia Beams – 90 feet long 73T • (2) Fascia Beams – 115 feet long 93T 6.5.1 Beam Delivery: An extraordinary coordination effort was vital to delivery of beams to the job site. MTA Bridge Engineers-TBTA denied access to the Throgs Neck Bridge. NYSDOT Region 11 denied access to Cross Bronx Expressway (Truck Route). There was no other choice except to go through local NYC streets. “Special Permit Vehicles” were needed by NYCDOT. The contractor needed the following approvals before NYCDOT could issue the permit: • NYSDOT Bridge Engineers • NYCDOT Bridge Engineers • NYCDOT Highway Design • PA Bridge Engineers • MTA Bridge Engineers • NYPD Motor Carrier unit A full coordination effort was undertaken with all agencies. A comprehensive geometric and field survey was conducted by a licensed Engineer to ensure that the route geometry would allow passage and safe, feasible turning movements. The condition of the existing roads (no sinkholes or depressions) through local streets within the designated routes was evaluated. The NYPD Motor Carrier unit stipulated that police escorts were required throughout NYC streets. NYS Police provided escort through Nassau’s County Streets. The project was delayed approximately 6 weeks to coordinate these efforts. Transport Vehicle: Oversized /Heavy haul axel tractor Trailers- (150’-5” length, 8’-6” Width, 12’-0” Height and 236,000 Ibs) Police Escorts: 15 NYC Police cruisers – 3 Tow trucks- 5 NYS Police cars Route: Start: George Washington Bridge (New Jersey) Destination: Nassau, NY110- Melville NY Allentown, NJ NJ-I 95-George Washington Bridge – 178th Street-Amsterdam – 125th Street - 125th Street Bridge – RFK Bridge (Triborough) – Hoyt Ave – I 278 Truck – I 278 – Ex 40 – Broadway – Queens Blvd (Inner Roadway) – Queens Blvd Outer Roadway under I 495 – Queens Blvd Inner Roadway after I 495 – Queens Blvd – Hillside Ave – SR 25 B- NY110 7. Bridge Erection Twenty-six (26) pre-stressed concrete girders (AASHTO Type V) superstructure were erected using a Liebherr LTM 1500-8.1 600 Ton Hydraulic Truck Crane. The crane was equipped with 135,000 kg (297,500LBS) counterweight and 247 M ton (272ton) capacity. Main Hook Block weighed 3,493 Kg (7,700 LBS). Boom was guyed and extended to 50M (164FT). Main hook block reeved with 8 parts load line. All rigging hardware including shackles, hooks, etc. had a minimum safety factor of 5:1. All hoisting was performed during traffic shutdowns of NY Route 110. 8. Exceeding Client/Owner Needs: Engaging all parties with informal partnering achieved a successful project wherein the owner, designer, resident engineer, and contractor resolved issues for the benefit of the project. One example was when the Contractor made the value engineering suggestion and the owner accepted it. 9. Final Cost Compared to the Budget Estimate This contract was completed for $ 56 million, well within the owner’s original budget. Books Robert A. Caro, The Power Broker by Vintage Books-Random House (1974); New York State Department of Transportation History of the Long Island State Parkway System, (1985).